Is Emulation Better Than The Real Thing?
By Lonnie WardNovember 23, 2001
Atari emulation is excellent on some fronts
such as the 2600 and not so good on others like the 5200. But this
isn't a real technical discussion on the merits of emulators (which
one is better,) this is more general. I'd like to talk about other issues like game play and is it a real experience and such other matters.
Now I've only had experience in classic Atari emulation (2600, 5200 and 7800)
but I have never used an emulator for the Lynx or the computers.
The Pros and Cons:
Emulation gives you a chance to play games you might never get to play.
Or allow you to relive
Pro: Less storage needed
You don't have to store the equipment and scour for parts in garage sales
hoping you're not getting ripped off or paying 5 bucks for something
that's worth 50 cents.
Con: No Human Interaction
Emulation takes out half the fun of going to swap meets and such.
But the down side of this is people paying outrageous amounts on auction sites like e-bay for
"garbage" because they're collector items. Listen
people, Atari games aren't worth a lot of money. Sort of like 8-tracks
there's very few Atari games that are worth over 10 bucks used (of course some say that some games
weren't worth 10 bucks when they were new.)
Pro: The games are free.
Con: ROM images are illegal to own.
However, most of the companies that made the games
either don't exist anymore or don't consider it worth the time or money to hassle people.
And there are other legal questions involved that pass over my head.
Now here's the argument that most people have debated for the last few years.
Does playing a game on an emulator constitute a real experience?
This is a similar argument about playing a Atari ( or any other console) version of an arcade game.
But to me, playing an emulated game is just like watching a movie
on tape or DVD instead of seeing it in the movie theater.
It's a mixed bag control wise. Some games you can use the mouse for
the paddle but unless you have one that lets
you use the space bar and arrow keys be prepared for finger cramps.
Another Pro of using emulation is that graphically Atari games
look just as good on a computer screen as they would on a TV. The same goes for sound.
Now a big Con is that some older emulators will run the games
faster then they originally played. Playing at such a fast speed
makes the games hard to play. Luckily, most Windows emulators have
worked out the problem of running the games too fast.
Also not all ROMs and emulators work together
correctly. That's the problem with 5200 and the 7800 emulators I've
tried. Some of the games never get past the Atari logo screen or some of the controls
needed to be tweaked and such.
Another piece of advice is stick to emulators that are at least Windows 95 compatible.
That way you don't have to use clunky DOS commands for resetting options and such.
You can get a front-end for the DOS emulators, but its just easier to get the
Windows version instead.
Also one last note: When you go to a emulator site like classicgaming.coms vault,
and they have the emulator author's web site listed, I advise going
to the website regularly. That way you have the latest version since some sites
don't update as quickly or as frequently as the actual author.
When it comes to emulators, I suggest you try many different ones
until you find the one that is best for you.